Assignment |Theological Thinking | Forum - to Begin with the Self
September 16, 2026 5:57 PM
1. Why is it important to begin with the Self as Dr. Copeland asserts?
Forum discussion: Identify 4 sentences from the text that seems to answer the prompt directly and briefly say why those sentences seem important to you.
Discussion (20)
Theological Thinking – To Begin with the Self:
Joyce M Guy
Let me start out with being an Afro American woman who is in her late 60s my struggle what's surviving has been nothing less then complicated and at times very abusive.
The picture may have of the black woman naked standing on a platform with a metal collar around her neck and a group of white men looking at her is the same today except they allow us to have our clothes on.
1 Black woman stand “at the crossroads of two of the most well-developed ideologies in America, that regarding women and that regarding [race].
This statement made me smile because as we know historically, we're always in the front row of fights. Let's look at are last few elections in the United States it was black women who Stood up and told this country what would happen if we elected the president we have. And let's not forget the black men who did not support the black women in this fight
2 We the people, the entire people of the nation, live in the time of slavery;
This statement is a very powerful one considering that over the years there has been what we call systematic slavery when it comes to the black women. We know that in this country over 800,000 black women have been economically displaced due to a loss of employment.
3 Freedom from enslavement was freedom for community and solidarity, for being human together.
I love this because it's a reminder of what the black community in United States should be all about. The prayers, singing and struggle of being a black woman is slave. I really feel that it doesn't get as much recognition regarding the mental and emotional and sexual abuse that continues to this day. Yeah, we still carry the cross by uplifting our male leadership in the Christian community.
4 To love her body, the freed Black woman had to learn to claim and enjoy her body—her dress, her self-presentation, her comportment.
Over the years we've seen the evolution of the beauty of a black woman she comes in all shapes sizes and shades of blackness. This is why I feel we spend so much time trying to look good because a part of looking good is feeling good. The way we dress carries the pride of the beauty of being black. Black women are now boldly representing their sexuality by not hiding behind sexual intimidation. “The freedom to Love herself”
Week 1:
This was an extremely hard lesson for me. Me being a black woman, I have read several history books and had conversations about black history, but I didn't expect to open this up in seminary school. Black history has always been traumatizing for me and hard to reconcile with.
Here are my 4 sentences:
1. Human beings have a distinct capacity to have been in communion with God.
I wonder if we as human beings had the capacity to be in communion with God why did slavery take place. Believing in God the Father, Jesus Christ & the Holy Spirit has been a life altering thing for me. It has made me want to be a better and different person.
2. Black women were made in the image of God
I believe that human beings were made in the image of God and that we have God living in us. After reading and refreshing myself with the horrible account of slavery, it makes me want to ask more questions and seek God even more. It reminds me that every day of my life is better than the last one and that I can't give up because other black women fought hard for me to have this freedom I have.
3. Fear of the Flesh
When Dr. Copeland talked about the Fear of the Flesh, it reignited with me when I was a younger me. I use to have a self image of myself that was not at all healthy. I was afraid of loving me and allowing people to get close to me because I was afraid of what I might say, what I would wear and how I might look. I appreciated her speaking about this. It helped me break my younger self free of fear and self-consciousness.
4. God created everything in Freedom.
I thank God that Freedom is a real thing and I have freedom in my life. And my question is if God gave all humans freedom how slavery happened.
I looked at a couple YouTube videos from Dr. Copeland because I needed to understand why she wrote some of these things and why she intergraded them into a lesson.
This is so strong and powerful. Something we are need to remember as we move through life.
I believe beginning with the Self is important because before we can fully understand, love, and care for others, we must first recognize our own humanity, acknowledge our experiences, and learn to love ourselves. My experiences with Lupus and the passing of my husband have taught me that healing is not simply about moving forward but also about rediscovering who I am.
“They defied the degradation of chattel slavery and refused to internalize a devaluation of self.” — M. Shawn Copeland, p. 28.
Living with Lupus since childhood has taught me that my illness does not define who I am. Although I have faced physical challenges throughout my life, I have learned to recognize my own worth beyond those limitations. This sentence reminds me that we should never allow our circumstances to determine our value as human beings.
“The freed people now had the possibility of taking up the responsibility of human living without restraint.” — M. Shawn Copeland, p. 35.
For many years, my identity centered on being a wife and caregiver. I often placed my husband's needs before my own. Since his passing, I have begun rediscovering who I am beyond those responsibilities. This sentence reminds me that I have the freedom to make choices for myself, pursue my interests, and embrace the next chapter of my life.
"In order to restore her body whole, the freed woman had to love her body; and to love her body meant dealing with the wounds of slavery." — M. Shawn Copeland, p. 36.
This sentence speaks to me because healing requires acknowledging what we have experienced rather than ignoring it. Living with Lupus has taught me to appreciate my body despite its limitations. My husband's passing has also brought a different kind of healing. After years of being his caregiver, I am learning to focus on myself, rediscover things I enjoy, and embrace a new chapter in my life.
In Copeland's discussion of Baby Suggs from Toni Morrison's Beloved, she emphasizes loving one's own heart and recognizing the importance of love, freedom, and being human. "To reject one’s heart is to reject all possibility and power of life, of freedom, of being human." — M. Shawn Copeland, p. 39.
This passage reminds me that loving ourselves is not selfish. For many years, I placed my own happiness and interests aside. Since my husband's passing, I have started doing things for myself again, such as taking classes, reading, line dancing, and spending time at the beach. These activities may seem small, but they represent my journey toward healing and rediscovering myself. I am learning that I can honor my past while also allowing myself to experience happiness and freedom.
(i) that human beings, created in the image and likeness of God (imago Dei),
have a distinct capacity for communion with God; (ii) that human beings
have a unique place in the cosmos God created; and (iii) that human beings
are made for communion with other living beings.
This was such an amazing text to read. I don't know if reading the text while serving tables in a very overpriced tourist town was the best idea to put in a mood to wait on some of the more enthusiastic diners was the best idea. But as soon as I was done with work I couldn't wait to finish reading the text. This sentence establishes an important blueprint for the self as it communes with God within the world that was created for us to communion with one another. That's the dream daily unveiling itself by God's revelation until his return.
The body is the medium through which the person as essential freedom achieves and realizes selfhood through communion with other embodied selves.
Yes, I am able to recognize my own uniqueness as well as everyone else's individuality. I am so excited to know everyone and genuinely pull to have authentic goodness with everyone I meet. But that may not be true of others. Others may have the same spirit of the cruel and abusive slave owner and for that reason I also know that my body myself is discernible and navigates carefully amongst other embodied selves that carry the spirit that wants to own you instead of recognizing God's ownership of you and Jesus's advocacy through this sacrifice and resurrection that transfers us from the imprisonment of sin into the protection of his mighty name.
You got to love it, you!
Son of Man, I do.
Jesus of Nazareth is the paradigm of enfleshing freedom, he is freedom enfleshed.
As Jesus was sacrificed and set us free from bondage he was refused by his people Israel. Even though he was born into his people Israel their refusal of him leads towards our acceptance of him. Our acceptance of him has led towards the story of his awaited return. But it is a story that belongs to all of us. Athena is a story that is specifically Greek. Pele is a story that is specifically Hawaiian. But Jesus's story is one that is designed so perfectly by God's Authorship it makes an access point for all generations to remember the ultimate act of love to free us from the slavery of sin.
God created everything in this cosmos, and we need to look at ourselves as the human beings created in the image and likeness of God Himself, to be in reverence with Him and with others in the world God has created.
But some others wanted to have it their way, to become like God themselves. To dominate others, to enforce slavery for their own personal gain.
We need to ask the question every day of our lives: Are we really doing or following Godʻs calling in our relationship with Him today?
Frank Mulec
Why is it important to begin with the self? I think that Dr. Copeland is asserting that “self” is our existence in the image of God, and that human actions that desecrate the humanity of anyone, as a beloved child of God, also desecrates God.
1. “However, the majority of slaveholders viewed the mere suggestion of common human nature to insinuate the possibility that, as Christians, the enslaved people might make a claim of fellowship upon them. Baptism represented a threat to the power differential, which sustained the positions of master and slave.” (pp. 18-19)
This gets to the heart of how people were and are able to justify the existence of chattel slavery and its descendents, including mass incarceration, economic and political disenfranchisement, and all of the ongoing, codified ways in which our society deems some as more human than others. If people can make themselves believe that some people are less than human, then they can reject the notion that they are made in the image of God and worthy of freedom. But baptism reminds us that we are all part of the kin-dom of God and threatens the system that upholds dehumanizing actions.
2. “Enslaved Black women and men disclosed a subtle, practical, and imaginative grasp of freedom, the conditions for its possibility, and its potential. They recognized that freedom was more than mere opposition to slavery.” (p. 29)
The white narrative of Black women and men as less than human, and the ways in which they enforced (and still enforce) systems of dominion over Black bodies often takes up all the space in history lessons, even when history is approached through a critical analytical lens. To embody and uphold a freer system, we must remember and amplify that those who are oppressed do not lose their intellect, their imagination, their love, their selves. All people envision and enact freedom of the self and assertion of their humanity even when their body is treated as property rather than as holy.
3. “The enslaved people understood God as the Author and Source of freedom. They apprehended freedom as God’s intention for them. Slaveholders tried to impose themselves between the slave and God and, to this end, manipulated Christian teaching.” (p. 30)
In my childhood church, I remember being taught (not by my Pastor, but by Sunday School teachers) that the Bible taught us that races should be kept separate. This was used as justification for our all-white church and censure of those in multiracial relationships. The “slaves obey your masters” passage also seemed to be a Sunday School memory verse every year, something for children to learn but never critically analyzed. Over 100 years after the official abolition of chattel slavery, the Christian teachings of my childhood manipulated biblical passages to justify ongoing oppression and to soften views of Virginia’s history. This was a direct descendent of the distortion and weaponizing of scripture to uphold the system of slavery.
“In calling the people to love their black flesh, she [Baby Suggs] conjures children, men, and women anew—makes them whole again.” (39)
This, I think, is the core of the idea that we must begin with the self. In loving one's own body (and mind and soul) fully, each person connects to the divine that is in us and is able to experience wholeness, freedom, and communion with God even when liberation as a right for all humans is absent or incomplete in the codified rules that uphold power structures in our broken world.
When deconstructing the fundamentals of theological anthropology, Dr. Copeland upholds three convictions:
- Human beings are created in the image and likeness of God and therefore have a distinct capacity for communion with God,
Human beings have a unique place in the cosmos (universe) God created, and
Human beings are made for communion with other living beings
Reflecting on these three convictions, the underlying thread of sameness is the concept of being created as human: living, breathing flesh with consciousness, born inherently free in God’s eyes. Therefore, slavocracy, as Dr. Copeland writes, goes against the very basis in which we were created.
In the purest form, before we are entangled within society’s classifications and power dynamics, we are created to exist as “self” and we alone (each human being) have a direct relationship with God (the Creator), whether we choose to nurture that relationship or not. For these reasons, when studying theological anthropology (God in relation with humanity), it is important to begin with the Self and all that the Self represents.
In Dr. Copeland’s book, Enfleshing Freedom, Ch.2 points out several statements that support why theologians should begin with the Self. However, four sentences from this chapter further support this claim. They are:
“Freedom from enslavement was freedom for God” (34).
“Freedom from enslavement was freedom for being human” (35).
“Freedom from enslavement was freedom for loving without restraint (35).
“Freedom from enslavement was freedom for community and solidarity, for being human together” (36).
“Freedom from enslavement was freedom for God”
An enslaved person was kept from worshipping freely and embracing the Holy Spirit in a manner that was freeing and safe. They would have to worship in secret places to express their spirituality and communion with God. If we were made to be in communion with God, the stripping of the ability to be in communion with Him is blasphemous.
“Freedom from enslavement was freedom for being human”
To live as a human, we are offered the vastness of humanity: to embrace individuality of thought, body, and spirit. We are made in God’s image, and just as He is free, He made us free - to choose, to love, to think. When our humanity is forced into a controlled box, we have been stripped of the gift that God gave us - freedom.
“Freedom from enslavement was freedom for loving without restraint
Under slavocracy, Black and Brown men, women, and children were forced to live in waking agony as they watched their loved ones stripped away from them, often never to see them again. God is love, and being made in His image, we are to be love as well. If we cannot freely love (physically and in spirit), this too is blasphemous and goes against what God created for us.
“Freedom from enslavement was freedom for community and solidarity, for being human together”
God made Eve for Adam, as expressed in Genesis. He made us to be in communion with others, as helpmates, as communal healers, etc. If we are restrained from upholding togetherness and the elements that make community - communal love, support, connection, grief, etc.- this rebuke of community limits our God-given responsibilities.
Why is it important to begin with the self?
I feel the sentences below matter to me because they remind me who I am as an African American woman, person, and parent, and because they let me reflect on my experiences, spiritual needs, growth, values, and truth about communing with God. It’s important to connect with the content while trying to understand complex ideas. My experiences are lived, memorable, humbling, knowable, and transformative, and I can read in the text that others have experienced something similar, even as ancestors did.
Pg. 31. ENFLESHING FREEDOM: Body, Race, and Being, M. Shawn Copeland
Alice Sewell reported that many enslaved people in her area
used to slip off in the woods on Sunday evening way down in the swamps to sing and pray to our own liking. We prayed for de day of freedom. We come four and five miles together to God dat if we don’t live to see it, to please let our chillen live to see a better day and be free, so dat dey can give honest and fair service to de Lord and all mankind everywhere.
What remarkable testament to the transcendent dimension of being human: enslaved people envisioned and prayed for a different future for their descendants. The unselfishness of such prayer astonishes and witnesses to hope, for the vast majority of Africans enslaved in the United States died in the bondage in which they were forced to live.
PG17 “Slavery was a business, a way of life, but most basically it was a lie. Nearly everyone touched by slavery learned to live with it by learning to live with that lie-a monstrous moral fiction that insulted God and human nature”. This is such a powerful statement. A warning really. Just how dangerous humans can be when blinded by greed and backed by numbers.
PG19 “Rethinking theological anthropology from the experience of Black women holds substantial social and cultural, moral and ethical, psychological and intellectual consequences for us all “. Reading the horrific accounts of the treatment of black slaves and specifically black women was very difficult for me, but vital. If any kind of healing or reparation is to occur these stories must never be lost and should be taught in every classroom in the world.
PG24 “White male slaveholders, their adolescent sons, slave traders, as well as patterrollers or slave-catchers, used Black women’s bodies with impunity” Again, something that must always be remembered as a warning of what humankind is capable of . The Epstein Files are an example of how soon we forget!
PG27 “By law and by custom, the enslaved people were deprived of the most rudimentary skills for meaningful, transformative education. Still, they risked beatings, mutilation, and disfigurement in order to learn to read and write”. This speaks to the amazing strength and tenacity of the individual, of the self. The belief in God’s promise of freedom.
Why is it important to begin with the Self , as Dr. Copeland asserts?
Since our lecture points us to the unique quality of freedom we were created with, and then further explains that it is within these relationships with all other created beings that we exist. So to think in terms of our freedom and the role it plays in these relationships, we must first look at self.
Reflecting on the 4 sentences that I felt strongest to reflect on.
1 “We come four and five miles to pray together to god dat if we don’t live to see it, to please let our children live to see a better day and be free, so dat dey can give honest and fair service to de lord and all mankind everywhere.”
Growing up in ministry, this has always been the platform I was raised in. Our families were the first generation that entered our country through military duty. Being the remnants of the South Pacific Colonial movement, our ancestors also faced great tragedies relative to abuse and deception. Once we were assimilated into the western world via military duty, we unfortunately experienced the painful results of racism in subtle ways. But I can say that the extreme treatment black women received at the hands of slavery was second to none that I know of. One can never fully feel what the enslaved black women endured, but to get just a glimpse of it makes one shudder to accept that it ever happened. We must never forget tragedies and evil such as this so that we can do our part in making sure it is not forgotten or ever takes place again.
2 For the enslaved woman in particular, freedom was linked inextricably and literally to the body.
Even under such cruelty and inhuman treatment that the black women experienced during slavery still shows ripples in today’s world. This cruel abuse continues in a much more subtle and broader sense to all women where evil resides. What the slave owners really created was living proof that what God created, man can never own! The black woman, to her credit, is living proof of that.
3 Incarnate spirit refuses to be bound. Escaping to freedom, purchasing one’s freedom or that of a loved one, fighting for freedom, offering up one’s own body for the life and freedom of another, dying for freedom, all were acts of redemption that aimed to restore Black bodily and psychic integrity.
The human spirit abounds even at the most trying of times. When many lose hope, those who are able to stand do it for those who can not. God’s people must stand for each other when some may be too weak to do so. This line reminds us of the sacrifices of the past and why we also must make sacrifices today that secure safety, respect, and compassion for all those who find themselves in danger of evil abuses.
4 For these, for all, for us, he gave his body in fidelity to the basileia theou, the reign of God, which opposes the reign of sin. Jesus of Nazareth is the paradigm of enfleshing freedom; he is freedom enfleshed.
We must fully understand that there is nothing that God has not experienced with us. The plight of the black woman makes me realize that it is events such as the one that mirrors Christ crucified and resurrected is freedom enfleshed.
1. From M Shawn Copeland book enfleshing we have freedom God created us in his image
my answer This tells me we are worthy and no human has control over me 2.God created humankind in his sic this tells me we are Gods children 3 In 1488 Pope Innocent the 8th excepted 100 Moor slaves from Ferdinand of spain and gave them to cardinals and nobility This shows me that religion eas used for profit and material gain 4. In 1644 the State of Maryland legislature drew up and affirmed that Negroes or to serve only Clearly this shows that control was what they wanted over Negroes for financial gain 100 percent profit